Let’s fix the concussions in football problem. This may seem
like the opposite of a solution. I’ll admit it’s counter-intuitive. Here’s what
you do. Take away protective gear. Let them have a jock strap and maybe shin
guards but that is all.
Football players
are the most concussion prone athletes in sports. These guys are so padded and protected they
begin to feel invincible. When your body is so shielded you have little fear of
using it as a battering ram. A full speed collision is not such a painful
proposition.
Stated clearly, the theory
is this: When your body is not padded and cushioned in every conceivable spot
you will use it in ways you wouldn’t were it not padded. This results in much
harder collisions with greater consequence. The no padding theory works for a number of reasons. One, you won’t find guys
still playing 15 or 20 years after their college career is over. Two, the hits
will be less devastating. Three, players will be much less likely to leap into
the air to make body sacrificing catches. Four, when your head is unprotected
you are much more careful with how you tackle and collide.
My theory that less protective equipment would actually be
safer comes from watching Rugby. Those guys are TOUGH! They wear very little protective gear. The
only head gear they wear is a sort of cloth helmet that looks like the helmets
worn by the football players of yesteryear. These are only worn by certain
players and not everyone who is eligible to wear one does.
There is another thing I think should be done to make football
a less injurious sport. End the use of pain blocking injections. If you can’t
play because of pain then don’t play. Pain is your body telling you something
is wrong. If a guy doesn’t have access
to powerful pain blocking drugs that allow him to continue playing though
injured, he won’t end up with a more grievous injury.
So, what do you think? Am I wrong? Tell me why I’m wrong. I’d
love to read your thoughts on this topic. I’d enjoy exploring it further and in
depth. Comment your responses, if you’d like.